Mike's Italian Restaurant

Discover authentic Italian flavors at Mike's Italian Restaurant in Baraboo, WI. Enjoy favorites like fettuccine alfredo, shrimp pasta, chicken parmesan, and more in a welcoming setting. Quick seating available!

Welcome to Mike's Italian Restaurant

Signature Dining Experience

Mike's Italian Restaurant
Mike's Italian Restaurant
Mike's Italian Restaurant
Mike's Italian Restaurant

Located at 630 W Pine St, Baraboo, WI, Mike's Italian Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience that brings authentic Italian flavors to your plate. This local gem is renowned for its warm ambiance and quick seating, making it a perfect spot for families and friends looking to enjoy a delicious meal together. With a menu that features everything from classic fettuccine alfredo to hearty stromboli, Mike's ensures that every visit satisfies your cravings for comfort food. Whether you're a local or just passing through, the atmosphere invites you to relax and indulge in home-cooked Italian dishes.

Location & Contact

Address

630 W Pine St, Baraboo, WI 53913, United States

Phone

+1 608-448-2278

Social Media

About

Mike's Italian Restaurant
Mike's Italian Restaurant
Mike's Italian Restaurant
Mike's Italian Restaurant

Since opening its doors, Mike's Italian Restaurant has become a beloved staple in Baraboo. Family-owned and operated, the eatery captures the essence of Italian dining through its rich flavors and hearty portions. The menu showcases a blend of traditional Italian recipes that have been perfected over the years. Regulars often rave about the shrimp pasta, chicken marsala, and the popular marinara sauce that keeps patrons coming back for more.

One unique aspect of Mike's Italian is its commitment to community. The restaurant hosts various local events and is known for supporting nearby schools and charities. Such initiatives create a warm atmosphere where guests feel connected to their surroundings. The ambiance inside echoes that of a quaint Italian bistro, with decor that reflects cultural pride and local history.

Whether it’s a celebratory dinner or a casual lunch, Mike's provides a welcoming space for all. Dining here is more than just a meal; it’s about creating moments. On any given Saturday night, the excitement fills the air as diners enjoy dishes like shrimp portafino, steak Milano Boz, or a comforting plate of tortellini. The staff is attentive and friendly, making every guest feel valued.

Mike's daily specials offer a delightful surprise, encouraging patrons to explore new flavors and culinary creations. Customers appreciate the dedication to service as they witness a passionate team committed to providing a truly exceptional dining experience.

Work Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-9 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Mike's Italian Restaurant boasts a diverse menu with over 88 dishes that cater to all tastes. Their selection of New York-style pizza is a highlight; choose from pepperoni, sausage, or a classic margarita. The pasta options are plentiful, including spaghetti and meatballs, fettuccine, and baked lasagna. Vegetarian options like eggplant parmesan and cheesy bread make it easy for everyone to find something they love.

Each dish is crafted with quality ingredients, ensuring every bite is flavorful. The restaurant also features ample seating, making it suitable for busy Friday nights and bustling Saturday dinners. For those who prefer calm dining, visiting during lunch hours can provide a more relaxed experience.

Mike's Italian Restaurant

The exterior of Mike's Italian Restaurant presents a charming and inviting facade, reflecting the warmth of the food within. Nestled conveniently on W Pine St, the restaurant exudes a cozy vibe that captures the essence of a traditional Italian eatery. Outdoor seating is available during warmer months, allowing diners to enjoy al fresco meals under the sun. The atmosphere embodies a community gathering spot where laughter and conversations blend seamlessly with the sizzling sounds of the kitchen. This welcoming exterior attracts both locals and tourists alike, making it a prominent stop in Baraboo.

Customer Reviews

Stayed at the AmericInn attached to Mike's while in the Baraboo area. Decided to eat dinner here. We had a medium size pizza and it was really big for medium size. It was cooked to perfection, very good taste, and the price was great also. The wait staff was friendly and attentive, refilling drinks as needed and checking how everything was. We had a conversation with the owner. He was very nice to talk with. The restaurant was large and very clean with nice decor. Overall, I highly recommend the place.

D
Dave P.

Under normal circumstances, I will wait until I've eaten at an establishment 3 or more times before I leave a review, but in this instance I'm making an exception. I have nothing but wonderful things to say about Mike's Italian...the first time my wife and I came here we'd both ordered the Chicken Marsala, and it was simply delicious. Our waitress, Anna, was extremely attentive and definitely helped with recommendations...I was very much torn between 3 options and was grateful for the help. I also had the pleasure of meeting the owner, Wendy, as well as Mike...and it was certainly a pleasure... extremely nice people who certainly made my wife and I want to come back. On our second trip I'd ordered the House Stromboli and it, too, was fantastic...a very ample portion to boot. Our waiter, Cody, was also extremely personable and very attentive. I am very, very much looking forward to subsequent visits here...and am *very* much looking forward to trying their white pizza. As a last aside, if Cody sees this....I WAS NOT FULL!

J
James L.

We were at Mikes February 6th A very very busy Friday night. We were an unexpected group of 10 ladies. We wanted to thank Mikes staff and Mike himself for the service! His hostess came to us made sure our drinks were full, and checked on our food making sure everything was good. We did wait a bit because it was a busy Friday night. Mike came out of the kitchen to greet us and many customers around us. I thought that was wonderful. So, we came back as a bigger group on Saturday the 7th and ate at Mikes again

S
Sharon C.

One of better Italian restaurants I have eaten at. Fast Friendly service, reasonable prices, large portion size, really good pasta with delicious sauces. Recommended!

D
Dave M.

Our group of 5 are from out of town, and we were looking for a restaurant to satisfy everyone's palate. We wanted a quality homemade meal - no fast food. We found Mike's and are really glad we did. Excellent food and service. We had pizza, cheese ravioli, the house burger, and a Philly cheesesteak. Would definitely return.

F
Flbeachygirl

The service was absolutely amazing. Servers and staff were so friendly to my daughter. Would definitely go here again. Pizza was great. Pasta was great. I'll have to pass on the cheesy bread and mushrooms appetizers for next time. They were OK.

L
Luke R.